What Does Ohio Mutual Insurance Group Do?

Total employees228
HeadquartersBucyrus
Founded1901

Ohio Mutual Insurance Group, founded in 1901, is a regional property and casualty insurer headquartered in Bucyrus, Ohio. The company operates exclusively through a network of independent agents, serving policyholders in Ohio, Connecticut, Indiana, Maine, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, and Vermont. Ohio Mutual is dedicated to providing quality insurance products, exceptional customer service, and maintaining financial strength for its members. They focus on building long-term relationships with their independent agency partners and policyholders, emphasizing trust and reliability.

Where Is Ohio Mutual Insurance Group's Headquarters?

HQ Function

The headquarters serves as the central operational hub, overseeing underwriting, claims processing, policy administration, IT, marketing, finance, human resources, and executive leadership for the entire group.

Notable Features:

A modern office campus designed to support efficient operations and provide a collaborative work environment for employees. The facility reflects the company's stability and commitment to the Bucyrus community.

Work Culture:

Ohio Mutual cultivates a work culture rooted in integrity, service, community engagement, and financial prudence. Employees often experience a supportive, stable environment that values professionalism, teamwork, and dedication to policyholders and agency partners.

HQ Significance:

The Bucyrus headquarters is the core of Ohio Mutual's operations, housing all key decision-making and support functions that enable the company to serve its policyholders and independent agents effectively across its operating states.

Values Reflected in HQ: The headquarters reflects Ohio Mutual's values of stability, community commitment, and customer focus. Its modern infrastructure signifies a dedication to operational excellence and adaptability in the insurance industry.

Location:

Ohio Mutual Insurance Group operates as a regional insurer within the United States and does not have a global presence. Its business activities are concentrated in Ohio, Connecticut, Indiana, Maine, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, and Vermont, where it supports policyholders through its network of independent agents.

Street Address:

1725 E. Mansfield Street

City:

Bucyrus

State/Province:

OH

Country:

USA

Where Else Does Ohio Mutual Insurance Group Operate Around the World?

Various locations across OH, CT, IN, ME, NH, RI, VT

Address: Not Applicable (Services provided via Independent Agent Network)

These independent agencies act as the local, accessible point of contact for policyholders, facilitating policy sales, providing personalized advice, claims assistance, and ongoing service within their respective communities and states served by Ohio Mutual.

Buying Intent Signals for Ohio Mutual Insurance Group

Highperformr Signals uncover buying intent and give you clear insights to target the right accounts at the right time — helping your sales, marketing, and GTM teams close more deals, faster.

Notable news
Hiring actively
Corporate Finance
Corporate Finance
Corporate Finance
Corporate Finance
Corporate Finance
*Example signal, not calculated in real time

Who's Leading Ohio Mutual Insurance Group? Meet the Executive Team

As of April 2025, Ohio Mutual Insurance Group' leadership includes:

Mark C. Russell - President & CEO
Chad A. Bardon - Senior Vice President & Chief Financial Officer
Jonathan M. D’Isidoro - Senior Vice President, Sales & Marketing
Susan E. Kent - Senior Vice President, Human Resources & Corporate Services
Todd M. Boyer - Senior Vice President, Chief Information Officer
Casie L. Grau - Senior Vice President, Chief Legal Officer & Corporate Secretary
Jeff Graves - Vice President, Chief Claims Officer

Who's Investing in Ohio Mutual Insurance Group?

Ohio Mutual Insurance Group has been backed by several prominent investors over the years, including:

As a mutual insurance company, Ohio Mutual Insurance Group is owned by its policyholders. It does not have external shareholders or investors in the traditional sense.

What Leadership Changes Has Ohio Mutual Insurance Group Seen Recently?

Hire2
Exits0

In the past year, Ohio Mutual Insurance Group has made key appointments to strengthen its executive and leadership team, particularly in claims and underwriting.

New Appointments:

Jeff Graves, Jeff Graves was appointed as Vice President, Chief Claims Officer to lead the company's claims department.
Ryan McClish, Ryan McClish was appointed as Vice President of Underwriting to manage all underwriting operations.

What Technology (Tech Stack) Is Used byOhio Mutual Insurance Group?

Discover the tools Ohio Mutual Insurance Group uses. Highperformr reveals the technologies powering your target accounts — helping your sales, marketing, and GTM teams prioritize smarter and close faster.

Ohio Mutual Insurance Group Email Formats and Examples

Ohio Mutual Insurance Group commonly uses the email format of an employee's first initial followed by their last name, at their domain 'ohmutual.com'.

[first_initial][last]@ohmutual.com

Format

jdoe@ohmutual.com

Example

85%

Success rate

What's the Latest News About Ohio Mutual Insurance Group?

Insurance JournalMarch 28, 2024

Ohio Mutual Insurance Group Names Graves Vice President, Chief Claims Officer

Ohio Mutual Insurance Group announced the appointment of Jeff Graves to the position of Vice President, Chief Claims Officer. Graves brings extensive experience to lead the company's claims department and strategic initiatives in claims handling....more

Insurance JournalFebruary 27, 2024

Ohio Mutual Insurance Group Names McClish Vice President of Underwriting

Ryan McClish has been appointed as Vice President of Underwriting at Ohio Mutual Insurance Group. In this role, McClish will oversee all underwriting operations, strategy, and practices for the insurer....more

Highperformr's free tools for company research

Explore Employees by Region or Country

See where a company’s workforce is located, by country or region.

View Funding Details

View past and recent funding rounds with amounts and investors.

Understand Revenue Insights

Understand company revenue estimates and financial scale.

Track Active Job Openings

Track active roles and hiring trends to spot growth signals.

Review Product and Offerings

Discover what a company offers—products, platforms, and solutions.

Get SIC or NAICS Codes

Get the company’s official SIC and NAICS classifications.

Analyze Website Traffic Trends

Analyze visitor volume, engagement, and top traffic sources.

Discover Social Profiles and Engagement

Explore LinkedIn, Twitter, and other active social profiles.

Identify Top Competitors

Identify top competitors based on similar business traits.

Research and Discover Companies with Highperformr — Smarter, Faster

Explore companies in depth — from the tech they use to recent funding, hiring trends, and buyer signals — all in one powerful view.

Highperformr AI helps you surface the right accounts and enrich your CRM with verified company and contact insights, so your teams can prioritize and engage faster.

  • Track intent signals to find buyers who are actively in-market
  • Enrich contacts and companies instantly, no need to switch tools
  • Automate workflows to stay ahead of every change
  • Connect your CRM & tools for seamless data sync and activation

Thousands of companies, including Ohio Mutual Insurance Group, are just a search away.