highperformr logo

Motorists Mutual Insurance Company's Overview

Total employees23
HeadquartersColumbus
Founded

Motorists Mutual Insurance Company was founded in 1928 in Columbus, Ohio, with a mission to provide quality insurance services and peace of mind to its policyholders. For decades, it served individuals and businesses, primarily in the Midwest and parts of the Eastern United States, offering a range of property and casualty insurance products. In 2017, Motorists Mutual Insurance Company, as part of the Motorists Insurance Group, merged with BrickStreet Mutual Insurance Company to form Encova Mutual Insurance Group (commonly known as Encova Insurance). This strategic merger created a larger, more diversified super-regional carrier. Encova Insurance continues the legacy of its predecessors by providing commercial and personal lines insurance, as well as life insurance products, through a network of independent agents. The company emphasizes strong agency partnerships, customer service, and financial stability.

Where is Motorists Mutual Insurance Company's Headquarters?

HQ Function

Historically served as the central administrative, underwriting, and claims processing hub for Motorists Mutual. Today, as part of Encova Insurance, it remains a key operational center supporting various functions of the merged entity.

Notable Features:

The building is a prominent structure on East Broad Street in Columbus, historically representing a stable financial institution. As an Encova office, it has likely been updated to support modern collaborative work environments and technological needs.

Work Culture:

Motorists Mutual historically fostered a work culture centered on policyholder service, reliability, and community engagement. Encova Insurance aims to cultivate an inclusive, innovative, and associate-focused culture, valuing integrity and collaboration.

HQ Significance:

The Columbus headquarters symbolized Motorists Mutual's deep roots in Ohio and its commitment to the region. For Encova Insurance, this location represents the heritage of one of its foundational companies and its continued presence in a key market.

Values Reflected in HQ: Historically, the headquarters reflected stability, trustworthiness, and a commitment to service. For Encova, the modernized facilities likely reflect values such as collaboration, efficiency, and forward-thinking.

Location:

Historically, Motorists Mutual Insurance Co. focused its operations primarily within the United States, concentrated in the Midwest and select Eastern states. As Encova Insurance, the company has expanded its geographical reach and is licensed to write business in a majority of U.S. states, from the Midwest to the East Coast and into the South. Encova Insurance does not maintain a significant physical operational presence outside the United States, concentrating its efforts on the domestic insurance market through its network of independent agency partners.

Street Address:

471 East Broad Street

City:

Columbus

State/Province:

Ohio

Country:

USA

Motorists Mutual Insurance Company's Global Presence

Charleston, West Virginia, USA

Address: 400 Quarrier St, Charleston, WV 25301, USA

Serves as a primary service and underwriting center for West Virginia and surrounding states, supporting Encova's strong market position in the Mid-Atlantic and Southeastern U.S.

Indianapolis, Indiana, USA

Address: 1 American Square, Suite 2300, Indianapolis, IN 46282, USA

Strengthens Encova's presence in the Midwest, providing localized services and support to independent agents and policyholders in Indiana and neighboring states.

Naperville, Illinois, USA

Address: 1240 E Diehl Rd, Suite 100, Naperville, IL 60563, USA

Facilitates growth and service delivery in the competitive Illinois market, focusing on building strong agent relationships.

Buying Intent Signals for Motorists Mutual Insurance Company

Highperformr Signals uncover buying intent and give you clear insights to target the right accounts at the right time — helping your sales, marketing, and GTM teams close more deals, faster.

Notable news
Hiring actively
Corporate Finance
Corporate Finance
Corporate Finance
Corporate Finance
Corporate Finance
*Example signal, not calculated in real time

Executive Team of Motorists Mutual Insurance Company

As of April 2025, Motorists Mutual Insurance Company' leadership includes:

John J. (JJ) Bishop - Chairman of the Board, President & Chief Executive Officer
Dave Dipaolo - Executive Vice President & Chief Operating Officer
Lisa Stover - Executive Vice President & Chief Financial Officer
Casey Waterman - Executive Vice President & Chief Information Officer
Joe Gottron - Executive Vice President, General Counsel & Secretary

Investors of Motorists Mutual Insurance Company

Motorists Mutual Insurance Company has been backed by several prominent investors over the years, including:

Motorists Mutual Insurance Company historically operated as a mutual insurance company, meaning it was owned by its policyholders rather than stockholders. Following the merger and formation of Encova Mutual Insurance Group, Encova Insurance continues to operate under a mutual holding company structure. This structure preserves the principle of policyholder ownership, ensuring the company's focus remains on serving its members and maintaining long-term financial strength, rather than catering to traditional stock market investors.

Executive New Hires/Exits in the Last 12 Months

Hire1
Exits0

Encova Insurance periodically announces leadership appointments and promotions. While specific high-profile external hires or departures can be infrequent, internal advancements reflect the company's growth and talent development.

New Appointments:

Paul Russell, Paul Russell was promoted to SVP, Chief Underwriting Officer, Commercial Lines at Encova Insurance, tasked with overseeing strategies and operations for commercial lines underwriting.

Technology (Tech Stack) used by Motorists Mutual Insurance Company

Discover the tools Motorists Mutual Insurance Company uses. Highperformr reveals the technologies powering your target accounts — helping your sales, marketing, and GTM teams prioritize smarter and close faster.

Motorists Mutual Insurance Company Email Formats and Examples

While Encova Insurance (formerly Motorists Mutual) does not publicly detail its exact email format conventions, businesses in the insurance sector commonly use patterns like 'firstinitial.lastname@domain.com' or 'firstname.lastname@domain.com'. For Encova Insurance, the email domain is @encova.com.

[first].[last]@encova.com or [first_initial][last]@encova.com

Format

jane.doe@encova.com

Example

80%

Success rate

News and media

Encova Insurance Website / PR NewswireFebruary 6, 2024

Encova Insurance Awarded 2024 Top Workplaces USA

Encova Insurance announced it has earned the 2024 Top Workplaces USA award, issued by Energage. This national recognition is based solely on employee feedback, highlighting Encova's commitment to creating a positive and engaging work environment for its associates....more

Encova Insurance Website / Ward BenchmarkingJuly 25, 2023

Encova Insurance Named to Ward’s 50 Top Performing Property-Casualty Insurers for 2023

Encova Insurance was named one of the Ward’s 50® top performing property-casualty insurers for 2023. This recognition by Ward Benchmarking, a leading provider of benchmarking and best practices for the insurance industry, signifies Encova's strong financial performance and operational excellence....more

Company Archives / Insurance Industry NewsApril 1, 2017

Motorists Insurance Group and BrickStreet Mutual Insurance Announce Merger to Form Encova Insurance

Motorists Insurance Group, the parent company of Motorists Mutual Insurance Co., and BrickStreet Mutual Insurance Company officially completed their affiliation, leading to the creation of Encova Mutual Insurance Group. This strategic merger combined the strengths of two established mutual insurers to form a super-regional carrier with an expanded footprint and enhanced capabilities....more

Highperformr’s free tools for company research

Explore Employees by Region or Country

See where a company’s workforce is located, by country or region.

View Funding Details

View past and recent funding rounds with amounts and investors.

Understand Revenue Insights

Understand company revenue estimates and financial scale.

Track Active Job Openings

Track active roles and hiring trends to spot growth signals.

Review Product and Offerings

Discover what a company offers—products, platforms, and solutions.

Get SIC or NAICS Codes

Get the company’s official SIC and NAICS classifications.

Analyze Website Traffic Trends

Analyze visitor volume, engagement, and top traffic sources.

Discover Social Profiles and Engagement

Explore LinkedIn, Twitter, and other active social profiles.

Identify Top Competitors

Identify top competitors based on similar business traits.

Research and Discover Companies with Highperformr — Smarter, Faster

Explore companies in depth — from the tech they use to recent funding, hiring trends, and buyer signals — all in one powerful view.

Highperformr AI helps you surface the right accounts and enrich your CRM with verified company and contact insights, so your teams can prioritize and engage faster.

  • Track intent signals to find buyers who are actively in-market
  • Enrich contacts and companies instantly, no need to switch tools
  • Automate workflows to stay ahead of every change
  • Connect your CRM & tools for seamless data sync and activation

Thousands of companies, including Motorists Mutual Insurance Company, are just a search away.